星期六, 10月 14, 2006

live organ harvesting

I have heard enough of Falun Gong's propaganda about the alleged live organ harvesting, and here are two additional sources for those who care about this issue. See another politician and a dissent, Bobby Fletcher. It is not that I don't think China has serious human-rights problems, but I am not convinced that what the Falun Gong people spread is ever close to the "truth." In my observation, the Falun Gong people have a strong tendency to exaggerate and to make unwarranted claims "in the name of telling truth."

7 則留言:

匿名 提到...

It seems to me also exaggeration that they are harvesting them for organs. It is posible with some death sentenced prisioners but about mass human orans business - this is hard to believe. However if they believe in all this crap they will take everything from their sect. So simple it is. If the boss will tell them that in China they make instant soup from their bro's they will take it.

bobby fletcher 提到...

There has been much discourse on issues like legal reform in China and Chinese society's moral ethical standards on death row inmates, by academics and media long before it was taken on by the Chinese government.

Here's an article from Phoenix TV:

http://www.phoenixtv.com/phoenixtv/72951501286277120/20050823/617113.shtml

"知情者透露:死刑犯在待?前,要通??血?取其生理信息,必???看守所同意;法院?行死刑,?察院???督?行。“如果不?得司法部?的?可,?院?死刑犯摘取器官??可能。”
一位不愿透露姓名的司法界?深人士?,司法部????机构提供死刑犯自愿捐?器官是有据可依的,具合法性前提。

??中,死刑犯自愿捐??体和器官的?道,也????大?媒体。一些死刑犯因捐?未果而留下最后“?憾”。

?位?深人士也坦承,?么多年?,不排除有死刑犯器官被“巧取”、“?取”的案例。但他?持??,?种情??是?案。

然而,?些“?案”的?累,?致了外界?死刑犯自愿捐?行?的普遍?疑"

大寶 提到...

放屁不遮羞。王文怡又是哪門子的 MD, PhD??? 法輪功的騙子請把本版其他的文章瞧清楚再來放宣傳品。Falun Gong people please stop lying: Wenyi Wang does *not* possess a Ph.D. from U of Chicago! 你們喊真善忍和講真相是比放你媽的屁還不如!

bobby fletcher 提到...

Dabao, I would love it if you could take my issues that I have blogged and confront Mr. Kilgour.

Thanks!

bobby fletcher 提到...

Dabao, PLEASE consider going to the screening for me. Here's my oped containing my thesis:

http://www.molokaitimes.com/articles/6114133346.asp

Thanks a bunch!

大寶 提到...

大寶之見是不要理會這些過氣政客附庸法輪功宣傳活動,他們喜歡且需要人氣,想上媒體版面。

trigonometric 提到...

Any such accusation related to human rights against any group, including accusations against the Communist Party of China, is a very serious accusation; but sadly, the ways pro-Falun Gong media(e.g. Epochtimes) report such events as if they were some forms of pranks, which indicates that they are very likely to not really care for human life, therefore they use such accusations as a way to win pity from the public so that they can survive.

任何此類人權方面的指控,包括對中國共產黨的指控,都是非常嚴肅的指控;但是,像大紀元等親法輪功媒體所用的報導手段,就好像這類的事情是惡作劇一般,這表示他們很可能根本不把人命當一回事,因此他們才會以此類的指控好博取公眾的同情並藉此生存。